Topping this year's list is Bristol Myers-Squibb,
followed by General Mills and IBM. Merck and HP round out this year's top five. Interestingly, not
a single top-ten finisher from the 2008 list finished among the top ten in 2009. Entergy, whose
holdings include ten nuclear and several coal-fired power plants, finished tenth in CRO's 2009
rankings; in 2008, the company finished 17th.
Only Intel, Cisco and Starbucks have made
the list all 10 years. Nearly 400 companies have appeared on the list over the past 10 years.
Bristol Myers-Squibb was consigned to CRO's "penalty box" last year due to regulatory enforcement
issues from 2006.
CRO's list for 2009 ranks only companies included on the Russell
1000 Index, which measures the performance of the large-cap segment of the US equity universe.
The list is based on publicly available information from such sources as non-secure websites,
government and regulatory sources, investment publications and NGO databases.
methodology employed by CRO for its list assigns a co-weighted average score to each company based
on performance in the areas of environment and employee relations (19.5%), climate change (16.5%),
human rights (16.0%), financial (12.5%), philanthropy (9.0%) and governance (7.0%).
change in methodology for 2009 (the weighting for governance decreased from 16% in 2008) has drawn
criticism from some quarters. Marcy Scott Lynn, Director of CSR for Sun Microsystems, reports in
her blog that CRO removed executive
compensation as a factor in its governance category, despite the proliferation of headlines
worldwide calling attention to the issue.
Upon the removal of executive compensation as a
factor, according to Lynn, 50 companies then tied with a top ranking in the governance category. As
a result, CRO reduced the weight given to governance as a corporate responsibility issue.